After
working with the Knex for a week I saw some flaws in the similarities and
differences I had previously seen between Knex and WPBD program. The one thing
that I noticed is that the cost to strength ratio seem to be relatively
similar. I took one of the bridge designs I had with the Knex and tried to make
it on WPBD and the cost came out to be approximately what I had expected it to
be with the Knex. The only real difference between the two is that WPBD allows
you to push your bridge past its limits. It lets you take parts out until the
remaining bars hold every last bit of the force. With the Knex that does not
really seem to be able to happen. The bridge either holds the weight or it does
not. It does not bend and turn bright red like the bridge designs made in WPBD.
I do believe
that working with Knex and working on making a real bridge that is made of
steel and spanning 20 feet or more is very different. With the Knex it seems
that we are just trying to see how much weight our bridge can hold. We are not
doing any calculations and do not have any real expectations. With a real
bridge we need to build a bridge that has to be able to hold a certain amount
of weight. It does not matter how much the bridge will cost because the bridge
has to be strong and reliable.
No comments:
Post a Comment